Data Visualizations

Preface: About the data

Where did we look for data?

Due to the scarcity of data on immigration detention, we had to look for data that exists under multiple government departments. Furthermore, the limited data on detention makes comparative data, such as with prison institutions, increasingly relevant.

We have looked at thousands of pages of literature and reports, and hundreds of data sources, including but not limited to the following:

Immigration Department Annual Reports
Immigration Department Enforcement Stats webpage
Correctional Services Department Stats webpage
Hong Kong Government submissions to United Nations bodies
LegCo press releases
Security Bureau Replies to Finance Committee
Hong Kong Government Data Portal
Census and Statistics Department website
Hong Kong Police Force website
Access to information requests (by others)
Access to information requests (filed by this project)
and more

What are the difficulties in finding data?

Thus, the difficulty of finding data on detainee population is in part due to the fact that detainees may be scattered across multiple institutions under the authority of multiple departments.

Another difficulty is that datasets that cover different time periods might not use the same measurement; this makes merging datasets to get a larger time period not possible.

Measurements and units

Data measures that have been used in the datasets we encountered include:

yearly admittances,
average daily population, and
a snapshot of the population at the end of the year.

Yearly admittances can illuminate the scale of turnover in a facility while average daily population could be useful to understand which years a facility is closer to capacity. However since average daily population would never exceed the capacity of the facility, a broader comparison between facilities may remain limited.

Click to skip to a section

Section 1: Immigration detention numbers and demographics

Where are people detained?

Facilities managed by the Immigration Department, Correctional Services Department, and more.

In fact, the Immigration Ordinance states immigration detainees can be held in essentially any police, immigration, prison facility as well as border control points.

The two main detention facilities managed by the Immigration Department are Castle Peak Bay Immigration Centre (CIC) and Ma Tau Kok Detention Centre (MTKDC). As of early 2021, a third detention facility is in use. The former prison Tai Tam Gap Correctional Institution (TTGI) was recommissioned as an immigration detention facility. It is run by the Correctional Services Department instead of the Immigration Department and detainees are subject to the Prison Rules.

How many people are detained yearly?

The number of detention cases may not equal the sum of yearly admittances into CIC and MTK because 1) one person can be admitted into more than one institution (ex. Admitted to MTK then transferred to CIC) and 2) there are detention facilities other than CIC and MTK. In this regard, the ‘number of detention cases’ is currently seen as the most relevant number in answering the question ‘How many people are detained for immigration purposes every year in Hong Kong?’.

How many people are admitted to CIC and MTKDC every year?

Download data (CIC)

Usage note: Please note the measurement units used. For example, yearly admissions and average daily population cannot be combined across time periods as they are different measurement units.

How many persons are released from CIC every year?

Where are the detainees in CIC from?

This chart shows the most common nationalities of detainees in CIC on Dec 31 of the past three years, with less common nationalities in “Other”.

The following chart shows all nationalities in detail on Dec 31 for a larger time period.

Usage note: “End of year” indicates the number of people on the last day of the year (ex. Dec 31, 2018). This means that the data shows the snapshot of the detainee population only on that day, and cannot be generalized to represent the whole year.

How old are the detainees in CIC?

This data shows a snapshot of the age groups in CIC on Dec 31, and thus cannot be generalized to represent the whole year.

What is the gender of detainees at CIC?

Click on the items in the legend to filter out different categories.

This graph shows yearly admissions into CIC by gender. Data prior to 2020 is not maintained. The Immigration Department has stated that admissions data of transgender persons was not maintained.

Where are the detainees in MTKDC from?

This data shows a snapshot of the nationalities of detainees in MTKDC on Dec 31, and thus cannot be generalized to represent the whole year.

How old are the detainees in MTKDC?

This data shows a snapshot of the age groups in MTKDC on Dec 31, and thus cannot be generalized to represent the whole year.

What is the gender of detainees at MTKDC?

This data shows a snapshot of MTKDC on Dec 31, and thus cannot be generalized to represent the whole year.

This graph shows yearly admissions into MTKDC by gender. Data prior to 2020 is not maintained. The Immigration Department has stated that admissions data of transgender persons was not maintained.

What are the nationalities of detainees in CIC and MTKDC?

This shows nationalities as a breakdown of yearly admittances to CIC and MTKDC, ie. the total number of people who enter the specified institution in a given year / time period.

How long are detainees held at CIC for?

These data points represent how long the detainee population at CIC has been held for at a given day, in this case, the last day of each month in a five-year period.

How long are detainees held at MTKDC for?

These data points represent how long the detainee population at MTKDC has been held for at a given day, in this case, the last day of each month in a five-year period.

Why are people held at CIC and MTKDC?

Grouped sections (CIC and MTKDC)

These data points represent the detainee population at CIC and MTK on a given day and the sections of the Immigration Ordinance (IO) that the people on that day were detained under. This dataset features the last day of each month in a three-year period.

Why are people held at CIC?

Grouped sections

These data points represent the detainee population at CIC on a given day and the sections of the Immigration Ordinance (IO) that the people on that day were detained under. This dataset features the last day of each month in a three-year period.

Why are people held at CIC?

Specific sections

These data points represent the detainee population at CIC on a given day and the specific sections of the Immigration Ordinance (IO) that the people on that day were detained under. This dataset features the last day of each month in a three-year period.

Why are people held at MTKDC?

Grouped sections

These data points represent the detainee population at MTKDC on a given day and the sections of the Immigration Ordinance (IO) that the people on that day were detained under. This dataset features the last day of each month in a three-year period.

Why are people held at MTKDC?

Specific sections

These data points represent the detainee population at MTKDC on a given day and the specific sections of the Immigration Ordinance (IO) that the people on that day were detained under. This dataset features the last day of each month in a three-year period.

Is there a recent snapshot of detainee demographic data?

These visualizations show demographic data of detainees who were at CIC on July 31, 2021. Click on the arrows to navigate to nationality, age, sex, and immigration status.

Who was detained at CIC in 2021?

These graphs show demographic data of detainees who were at CIC on the end of each month of 2021. Click on the arrows to navigate to nationality, age, sex, and immigration status.

Who was detained at CIC in the past five years?

These graphs show demographic data of detainees who were at CIC on the end of each month between 2017 and early 2022. Click on the arrows to navigate to nationality, age, sex, and immigration status.

How many people are detained at TTGCI?

Tai Tam Gap Correctional Institution (TTGCI) was reopened on 28 May 2021 as an immigration detention facility.

This data shows a snapshot of TTGCI on the last day of each month, and thus cannot be generalized to represent the whole year.

How many minors are held at TMCJH?

CIC and TTG are institutions that only hold adult detainees. Migrant children would be held at Tuen Mun Children and Juvenile Home, which holds both local and migrant children.

Click to skip to a section

Section 2: Immigration detention conditions

Are detainees strip searched?

Where are detainees strip searched?

How many complaints are made by detainees every year?

Which institution are they made at?

How many complaints (in total) are filed against the Immigration Department?

What do we know about violence in detention?

There is data on physical confrontations at the two main detention facilities managed by the ImmD. This graph shows data from CIC.

Is there a lot of violence?

This graph shows the number of physical confrontations at CIC compared to the number of admittances to CIC.

How many people are injured as a result?

How many detainees receive penalties as a result?

What do we know about violence in MTKDC?

How many emergency ambulances are sent to immigration detention facilities?

Click on the arrows to navigate between the visualizations.

Why were emergency ambulances sent to immigration detention facilities?

How many Justices of the Peace visits were made to CIC and MTKDC?

Justices of the Peace (JPs) visit designated institutions and acts as a channel for people in prisons, detention facilities, and hospitals to express views and file complaints. JPs also make suggestions to improve institutional facilities and services.

What complaints, requests, and suggestions were made?

Complaints and requests made to JPs by category. Suggestions made by JPs by category.

Click to skip to a section

Section 3: Immigration Department enforcement actions

What enforcement actions are conducted by the Immigration Department?

Deportation vs Removal Deportation occurs when a person commits an offence and is banned from the territory for a fixed period of time or for life. Removal occurs to “restore the person to the place from whence [they] came” with there is no ban on return.

How many (non-ethnic-Chinese) persons are removed every year?

This chart shows the number of non-ethnic Chinese (NEC) persons removed from Hong Kong every year, and is not limited only to non-refoulement claimants. NEC is a category defined by the government.

How many persons are arrested for immigration offences?

This graph indicates the number of persons arrested and not the number of persons prosecuted (ie. charged) nor convicted (ie. found guilty). Not all those arrested will necessarily be prosecuted, and not all those prosecuted will necessarily be convicted.

Of those arrested, how many have been convicted?

What are convictions? After a person is arrested, they may be prosecuted. If after trial they are found guilty, then they are convicted. In other words, arrested persons are not necessarily guilty, while convicted persons have been found guilty.

Click to skip to a section

Section 4: Refugee / Non-refoulement / USM Claims

Hong Kong does not legally recognize refugees, but refugees can apply for a status called non-refoulement. Having non-refoulement status prevents the person from being deported while they face the risk of serious harm or death upon being returned, thus allowing them to stay in Hong Kong temporarily.

The process to apply for non-refoulement in Hong Kong is called the Unified Screening Mechanism. The initial application stage is managed by the Immigration Department. If the applicant receives a rejection, they can appeal to the Torture Claims Appeal Board (TCAB). If the applicant then receives a rejection at the TCAB stage, they might have the option to bring their case to judicial review. If their case is approved in judicial review, it would be required to be reviewed again by the TCAB.

How many non-refoulement claims are filed and determined every year?

“Claims made” are claims filed by non-refoulement applicants. “Claims determined” are claims where a decision was made on the claim (ie. approved / rejected). “Outstanding claims” refers to claims that are still being processed through the system.

Who is currently in the process of their USM claim?

Click on the arrows to see demographics of USM claimants (at Sept 2021) with outstanding (ie. pending) claims. Demographics include nationality, age, sex, and immigration status.

What are the nationalities of the substantiated claimants in the USM?

A substantiated non-refoulement claim is one that has been approved, which allows the claimant to remain in the territory.

An increasingly large proportion of USM claims are substantiated on appeal.

This suggests a high rejection rate of USM claims at the initial application stage to the government.

80% of applications to work by USM claimants have been approved.

Non-refoulement claimants whose claims have been approved are not automatically granted the right to work. In order to work, one would need to apply separately to the Immigration Department. The request for approval to work is not considered through a formal system but on a “case-by-case” and “exceptional basis“.

Click to skip to a section

Section 5: Expenditures

How much is spent in relation to non-refoulement claimants?

How much is spent on repatriating people?

These figures indicate expenditure involved with repatriation of persons, including but not limited to non-refoulement claimants.

How much does it cost to detain people at CIC?

How much does it cost to detain people at MTKDC?

How much does it cost to detain people at other control points managed by the Immigration Department?

Click to skip to a section